Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pleasant Ridge

Ashli Ward 2 months ago

Very large pizzas. Great options. Good drinks. Clean restaurant and nice bathroom. Decent parking available. Pizza was little burnt and they did make it ok by making sure the next pizza was great and also offer a $5 discount. Would like more diverse music since it is so loud. Overall great experience.

Dennis45251 5 months ago

Wonderful place to dine. Excellent subs and pizza. Some of the biggest slices of pizza I have seen and garlic bread as long as your arm. The upstairs bar was wonderful with inside and balcony seating. Bartenders Coe and Cat were very friendly and professional. My favorite drink was the broken hatchet. When they make it in front of you it's quite a show. I will recommend and also revisit again and again.

Jack Nguyen 6 months ago

Very good new york style pizza. Everything from how they prepare the pizzas to how they sell pizza by the slice is great! The flavors arent going to be anything new or revolutionary but they make their pizzas simple and make them right! I got the cheese and pepperoni to get a baseline idea of how everything tasted and I was not disappointed! Crusts were thin and crisp, and everything tasted fresh. The location itself is also very clean and never too crowded! Perhaps the most important aspect that I appreciated the most was the service! Everyone was polite and helpful and spent a decent time talking to me about different reccomendations on the menu!

Alek Elo a year ago

It has been a week now being in Cincinnati, after searching the web looking for dinner spots I came across this place, came in looking for a pizza and left with a changed perspective on the pizza and service industry. Everybody part of the staff was super easy going and made the experience smooth, especially Chris at the front hooked me and my buddy up with some great eats and even got us top floor access to the rooftop. Definitely will be coming back, from his hospitality to the food, this place is doing it right!

Nick Alex a year ago

I want to start this review off with this. GO HERE. Order their food. It is good and it is a business worth supporting. Their pizza is so much better than most…… however, our last visit was less than good. We ordered the “The Boss” and “The Naples” the Naples crust was a bit burnt and one piece was void of cheese, sauce or any toppings. (This is coming from someone who loves those bubbles and worked in a pizza shop for 4 years) To add the crust was burnt. I like a charred crust but this was a bit too much. As for The Boss pizza, half was burnt and half wasn’t. For an $18 small pizzas, this is just unfortunate. This is our second time here and the first time was great. (We ate in at that time) support this business and go here. It’s good pizza but this was just a misfire.